Where are the Best Italian Restaurants in Salem, NH?

Pasta dish at an Italian restaurant

The weather is getting cooler, which means it’s the perfect time to visit the best Italian restaurants in Salem, NH and enjoy your favorite Italian dish. There are many restaurants to choose from, and to make things easier, the team at Rockingham Toyota has compiled a list of our favorite Italian restaurants in Salem, NH. Let us know your top pick the next time you’re visiting for a routine service appointment.

Ralphie’s Care Italiano

For the best traditional Italian comfort food served in an old-school space, Ralphie’s Care Italiano is a must-visit! At Ralphie’s, they use only the finest and freshest ingredients in their recipes, which were handed down from generation to generation. Whether you have a major craving for their hand-breaded cutlets, their famous red sauce, or extra-large hand-rolled meatballs, you are sure to find your new favorite dishes right here!

Address: 91 S Broadway, Salem, NH 03079

Amore Pizza Restaurant

The family tradition at Amore Pizza Restaurant is not like the rest, because they “start from scratch and make the best.” Stop by and relax in their casual and spacious dining room with family and friends as you enjoy your favorite Italian dish. Popular menu items include antipasto salad, tomato soup, American sub, calzones, pizza made your way, and of course, homemade cannolis for dessert.

Address: 314 S Broadway # E, Salem, NH 03079

Windham Restaurant

Just a short drive from Salem is the Windham Restaurant. Set in an 1812 house, this local restaurant offers an eclectic American fare and simple decor that’s perfect for a meal with friends, co-workers, or a date night out. This top-rated restaurant offers a vast, affordable menu of dishes like calamari, caesar salad, chicken parmigiana, baked scallops, and the ribeye.

Address: 59 Range Rd, Windham, NH 03087

The Colosseum Restaurant

For traditional Italian dishes in a spacious and relaxing area with booths and a convivial bar, come and visit the Colosseum Restaurant near Lawrence. This local hot spot wants you to taste the flavors of southern Italian cuisine. With more than 30 years of award-winning dishes created by Chef Annibale Todesca and family, you and your guests are in for one incredible meal. A few fan-favorites include fried calamari, spaghetti marinara, fettuccine alfredo, and homemade lasagna.

Address: 264 N Broadway # 101, Salem, NH 03079

Trattoria Amalfi

When you visit Trattoria Amalfi from the Methuen area, you can expect a place with a mural-filled backdrop with ultra-cozy booths, and leafy, rustic accents as you enjoy delicious traditional Italian dishes. If you are coming to visit for the first time, some popular recommendations include stuffed mushrooms, calamari fritti, the shrimp cocktail, veal marsala, chicken piccata, and the shrimp scampi.

Address: 385 S Broadway, Salem, NH 03079

Visit Rockingham Toyota Today!

Whether you want the best restaurants in Salem, where to go for Italian restaurants in Salem, NH, or need assistance finding a quality used Toyota vehicle, the team at Rockingham Toyota is standing by ready to assist. We provide the highest quality of service every time you visit. Give us a call today!

More From Rockingham Toyota

  • Explore the 2020 Toyota RAV4 Trim Levels

    The 2020 Toyota RAV4 trim levels have starting prices that range between $25,950 MSRP* and $35,280 MSRP*, making the new Toyota RAV4 the perfect choice for many Haverhill families. Finding the RAV4 configuration that meets your needs without breaking the bank has never been easier than with the team at Rockingham Toyota. Explore each of the…

  • 2020 Toyota Highlander Configurations

    How much does a Toyota Highlander cost? The affordably-priced 2020 Toyota Highlander starts at $34,600 MSRP and features plenty of high-tech technology features, a spacious interior, and excellent performance capabilities. No matter the Highlander trim level that you choose for your Haverhill commute, you gain access to a top-rated SUV that comes equipped with the…

  • How Much Can a Toyota Tacoma Tow

    If you’ve been dreaming of being handed the keys to your new pickup truck, you’ve probably thought about a Toyota truck, specifically, a 2020 Toyota Tacoma. Are you ready to learn more about the Toyota Tacoma, like how much can a Toyota Tacoma tow? Learn more about the Toyota Tacoma towing capacity, as well as…

Saved Vehicles ×


You don't have any saved vehicles!

Look for this link on your favorites:


Once you've saved some vehicles, you can view them here at any time.

Contact Us ×


Call Now

412 South Broadway • Salem, NH 03079

Get Directions

Today's Hours:

Open Today! Sales: 11am-5pm

Service: Closed

Parts: Closed

Rockingham Toyota 42.7481988, -71.2042747.